Don’t Be Fooled: How You Can Detect Business Fraud

I’ve spent decades investigating business fraud as a forensic accountant and expert witness, often at the state and federal levels. The lessons I’ve learned about human behavior and motivation during this time have benefitted my clients in surprising ways. According to the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners, the typical organization loses 5 percent of revenue each year to fraud. The median loss caused by fraud is $145,000, with the fraud lasting a span of 18 months before detection. Every business owner is vulnerable.

As business owners, we call upon other professionals to help us with business matters through specific “lenses.” An attorney assists on legal matters while a CPA focuses on taxes, for instance. But, as a forensic accountant, I’ve learned to draw upon a combination of these lenses to determine how a business person likely reacted—or is bound to react—to certain situations. As D. Larry Crumbly, Lester E. Heitger and G. Stevenson Smith outline in the book Forensic and Investigative Accounting,a forensic accountant’s knowledge base should include accounting, law, criminology and investigative auditing. Looking at the situation from different lenses is critical to exposing fraud.

While I agree with the authors, I’ve added one more important lens to my arsenal over the years: an understanding of human behavior. An understanding of motivation, specifically, can be a reliable predictor of behavior. Perhaps the strongest example of this—within my own experience—was discovered during the U.S. Senate’s Whitewater investigation 20 years ago.

By the time I was named the sole investigative accountant on the case, the Whitewater matter was well scrutinized. It was perhaps the most scrutinized case of potential tax fraud in U.S. history, serving as the subject of hundreds of articles, news investigations, a Resolution Trust Corporation investigation and U.S. House investigation, as well as an investigation by Special Prosecutor Kenneth Starr. Yet, amidst this intense scrutiny, I was the first to discover a previous land deal with Jim McDougal prior to the Whitewater deal. What led me to this discovery? When it comes down to it—based on human nature—people tend to act and react similarly when investing money. Therefore, I had a hunch that Whitewater wasn’t the Clintons’ first land deal.

What I knew about human behavior dictated the following: Individuals are not likely to invest that much money (approximately then-Governor Bill Clinton’s annual salary at the time) on a first time investment with a referred promoter. I believed that most people would try a smaller investment with a promoter first. If that proved successful, then they would make the larger investment. It comes down to the idea of loss aversion, or the tendency for risk-taking to be motivated more by an aversion to loss than a penchant for gain. Experience tends to lessen the aversion.How can these types of behavioral insights translate to your own business dealings? First, don’t ignore instinct. If you suspect deposits are short this month, there’s too much radio silence by an executor in a family-owned entity, or any other fraud red flags: investigate it. Even if the evidence under one “lens” seems to be in order, following a trail through another lens may show an entirely different picture. A forensic accountant can help you do that. We’re often brought in to help with high-risk audits, family business and partnership conflicts, and potentially messy situations like a divorce among business owners. However, working with a forensic accountant proactively to recommend systems of internal controls can deter or assist in reducing the impact of potential fraud on your business.

June 25, 2014

Client Spotlight

As a business owner, what can you do to eliminate tax surprises? Before jumping on tax liability insurance to insure your tax bill, consider what…
From accountant to owner, and now to a successful exit! Amir Kamel proved that “everything good takes time”—including walking away on your own terms. Read…
After waiting 11 years for his visa, Amir Kamel’s journey from Cairo to building a multi-million dollar Texas business is a true masterclass in grit,…
Used wisely, 100% bonus depreciation can fuel growth and protect cash flow; used poorly, it can create unnecessary debt and future tax friction….
Discover how this San Antonio entrepreneur transitioned from managing communities to constructing them—doubling his commercial construction firm’s size year over year….
In the eyes of the IRS, student-athletes landing NIL deals are now self-run businesses. Learn the tax implications and four golden rules critical to their…
Disputes in closely held businesses rarely stem from simple math errors. Instead, they arise from “creative” accounting that obscures the business’s true economic reality….
While you might not be signing an addendum with the Acting Attorney General, you CAN use closing agreements and statutes of limitation to create your…
When building wealth in Texas, poor planning can result in hefty taxation as you earn your way to the top….
A new precedent is forming in the tax courts that can cost even innocent taxpayers hundreds of thousands of dollars….
George Clooney’s recent relocation to France highlights a complex financial dilemma: maintain dual citizenship and face dual tax systems, or renounce U.S. citizenship and trigger…
A business seizure is a last-ditch effort following many other attempts at tax collections. Here’s what to watch for and how to respond….

Blogs and Articles

Do Businesses Need Tax Liability Insurance?

As a business owner, what can you do to eliminate tax surprises? Before jumping on tax liability insurance to insure your tax bill, consider what...

Do Businesses Need Tax Liability Insurance?

Read More

Princess Professional

From accountant to owner, and now to a successful exit! Amir Kamel proved that "everything good takes time"—including walking away on your own terms. Read...

Princess Professional

Read More

Princess Beauty Supply

After waiting 11 years for his visa, Amir Kamel's journey from Cairo to building a multi-million dollar Texas business is a true masterclass in grit,...

Princess Beauty Supply

Read More

100% Bonus Depreciation: Hits and Misses

Used wisely, 100% bonus depreciation can fuel growth and protect cash flow; used poorly, it can create unnecessary debt and future tax friction....

100% Bonus Depreciation: Hits and Misses

Read More

DJS Resources

Discover how this San Antonio entrepreneur transitioned from managing communities to constructing them—doubling his commercial construction firm's size year over year....

DJS Resources

Read More

College Athlete NIL Tax Implications: When Fantasy Becomes Reality

In the eyes of the IRS, student-athletes landing NIL deals are now self-run businesses. Learn the tax implications and four golden rules critical to their...

College Athlete NIL Tax Implications: When Fantasy Becomes Reality

Read More

Profit-Sharing Disputes: IDing What Went Wrong

Disputes in closely held businesses rarely stem from simple math errors. Instead, they arise from "creative" accounting that obscures the business's true economic reality....

Profit-Sharing Disputes: IDing What Went Wrong

Read More

What’s the Deal with Trump’s Forever Tax-Immunity Loophole?

While you might not be signing an addendum with the Acting Attorney General, you CAN use closing agreements and statutes of limitation to create your...

What’s the Deal with Trump’s Forever Tax-Immunity Loophole?

Read More

Secret Texas Wealth Tax Traps

When building wealth in Texas, poor planning can result in hefty taxation as you earn your way to the top....

Secret Texas Wealth Tax Traps

Read More

How Long to Keep Tax Records? Forever Might Be Best 

A new precedent is forming in the tax courts that can cost even innocent taxpayers hundreds of thousands of dollars....

How Long to Keep Tax Records? Forever Might Be Best 

Read More

George Clooney’s Exit Tax Dilemma

George Clooney's recent relocation to France highlights a complex financial dilemma: maintain dual citizenship and face dual tax systems, or renounce U.S. citizenship and trigger...

George Clooney’s Exit Tax Dilemma

Read More

Avoiding a Business Seizure for Nonpayment of Taxes

A business seizure is a last-ditch effort following many other attempts at tax collections. Here’s what to watch for and how to respond....

Avoiding a Business Seizure for Nonpayment of Taxes

Read More

4NS-Supply

How do you go from zero sales to 800% growth while maintaining a medical career? Dr. Paul Pallan shares his story of dual-career success and...

4NS-Supply

Read More

Better Tax Preparer Oversight May Be on the Way

Tax preparer oversight might soon be getting a rehaul thanks to a bipartisan Senate bill that aims to impose stricter standards and penalties for misconduct....

Better Tax Preparer Oversight May Be on the Way

Read More

J. Anthony’s Refrigeration

From U.S. Navy technical training to founding J. Anthony’s Refrigeration in 1988, learn how John Bianchi’s commitment to excellence and high-level expertise built a trusted...

J. Anthony’s Refrigeration

Read More

Now Accepting New Clients

Let’s Start the Conversation

Let’s take a look at your finances together. We offer a complimentary 1-hour call to review your past tax returns. If we see a way to help you, we will.

Want to receive tax strategies and tips direct to your inbox?

Name(Required)