The Goldilocks Rule for Tax Withholding

If you’re like half of Americans this year, you are more dependent on your tax refund to pay for necessities than you have been in the past. But paying more taxes than necessary shouldn’t be part of your game plan. 

There’s a Goldilocks Rule for tax withholding that many payrolled Americans get wrong. It sounds quite simple: Finding the “just right” amount of tax to withhold from your paycheck—not too much and not too little. The goal is to have your withholding closely match your actual tax liability. 

But if it were simple in practice, you would never get a refund large enough to fund a family vacation or a tax bill so hefty, you’re worried how in the world you’ll pay it.  

The risk in over- or under-paying lies in the subcontext: 

  • Withholding too much and getting a significant refund means you’ve essentially lent the government your money interest-free. That’s money that you could have, instead, put to work by investing it, using it to pay down debt, or funding a business or other cause. 
  • Withholding too little means you might owe taxes, penalties, and interest once you file. The extra penalties and interest can really add up, and suddenly you owe much more than you should have had to pay (once again, benefiting the government more than yourself). 

If you’re a W-4 employee, check and adjust your withholding regularly to avoid surprises at tax time. At minimum, do this annually (especially if your last return included a significant refund or bill) and after these significant changes:

  • Salary changes—If your salary or other income sources have increased or decreased, review your income tax rate. It may have changed as well, which can affect the amount you withhold.  
  • Spouse or dependent changes—Did your spouse change jobs? Did a young-adult child graduate or leave school? Did you take on an elderly parent as a dependent? Or did your family experience a birth, death, or other change?
  • Other income sources—Do you expect changes to additional income sources like interest, dividends, or retirement income that don’t have withholding? Will you incur losses, medical expenses, or other reasons to claim an itemized deduction? 
  • Tax regulations—Changes to tax policies and perhaps even tax rate changes are expected this year. When that happens, be sure to review your withholding strategy. 

Many families or individuals juggle several income streams that include a combination of jobs that require W-4 withholding and other self-employment, investment, or side business income. Some people use the “extra withholding” option on the W-4 to “pre-pay” taxes for these extra income streams, but consider your options carefully. It’s vital to discuss your unique income profile with a tax professional to understand how these income sources could affect your withholding.  

The Goldilocks Rule is a great way to maximize your money. When you get it “just right,” you can hold onto your hard-earned dollars and use them or invest them immediately instead of waiting for the federal government to send your “free loan” back to you. Feel free to contact us with questions.  

Photo from 123rf.com 

Client Spotlights

A terrifying home invasion involving men with masks and guns set Pam Wood on an unexpected path to business ownership in 1981.
What happens when you combine a passion for creating, a knack for business, and deep family values? For Scott Klingler, owner of MergeWorks, it resulted in a thriving family business known for its…
Bessie M. Irizarry loves embracing a good challenge. It’s one of the many reasons she’s earned respect as a female engineer and business owner in predominantly male-dominated fields.
San Antonio native Mark Lopez can’t recall a time he didn’t envision himself following the footsteps of his father, a project manager, into the construction business.
Siew Pang knows that the key to unlocking the American dream can be discovered by embracing unexpected opportunities.
If you’re a San Antonian, you may not want to imagine your weekend without brunch at the city’s beloved Magnolia Pancake Haus.
Greg Thompson has long respected money and how it can catalyze greater things.
You may not be aware of it, but Don Lasseter has helped you throw a party. How do we know that? He’s the franchise owner of six San Antonio-area Party City stores.
Land surveyors aren’t known for exceptional customer service. But why shouldn’t they be? David Breaux set out in 1998 to prove that treating customers right can pay off in any industry.
When Lance Rose sees a business need, he fills it. That’s how he and Terri, his wife of 30 years, have evolved into the proud owners of OverWatch Enterprises, LLC, a cutting-edge security services company.
Matt and Lara Bruhn met while in graduate school at Harvard. He served as an officer and F-15C pilot with the U.S. Air Force.
Growing up in Piedras Negras, Coahuila, Mexico—just south of Texas along the Rio Grande—Oscar E. Flores dreamed of becoming a designer.

Blogs and Articles

The Goldilocks Rule for Tax Withholding

How Inherited Assets Affect Your Taxes

Getting Hit by Someone Else’s Bankruptcy

Welcome to Texas: Cutting Tax Ties with Your Previous State

Reaching the Unreachable IRS

How Is Costco Gold Taxed?

Yes, You Do Still Have to File Taxes

Retirement Plan Perks for Texas Small Businesses

Top 6 Worst Social Media Tax Tips

What’s Happening with the Corporate Transparency Act?

Love & Marriage & Your Business Assets

How Small Business Owners Reduce Taxable Income

Spot These Tax Scam Signs Before It’s Too Late