The Social Security Tax Trap

Taxes are behind one of the oldest business-owner curses: The more you pay yourself, the more it could cost you in the long run. A huge culprit in this scenario is the Social Security tax. Most often, what you put into Social Security is nowhere near what you get out of it in benefits. And once you reach a certain salary level, it can become a real sticking point. Balancing the wages you deserve with an income that is tax-effective is the key.

The issue here is with your estimated primary insurance amount (PIA), which is the number the Federal government uses to estimate the benefits you’ll receive if you retire at a normal retirement age (currently set at 62). The PIA is calculated using ‘bend points’ based on your average indexed monthly earnings. According to the Social Security Administration, an individual who becomes eligible in 2014 (by retiring at 62 or becoming disabled) has a PIA of:

A) Ninety (90) percent of the first $816 of his/her average indexed monthly earnings, plus

B) Thirty-two (32) percent of his/her average indexed monthly earnings over $816 and through $4,917, plus

C) Fifteen (15) percent of his/her average indexed monthly earnings over $4,917.

If your business is structured in a way that makes you an employee (a Corporation or S Corp), you’ve become accustomed to paying the complete 15.3 percent FICA (Social Security and Medicare) tax: more than any other wage earner. But, alas, your Social Security payout remains the same as everyone else’s. So once your average indexed monthly earnings exceed $59,004, you’re paying 15.3 percent on those earnings with only a 15 percent return on your investment. Essentially, you’re just “trading dollars” at that point. What’s worse, those dollars won’t come back into your life until you retire. The only beacon of light after that is a wage base cap of $117,000, with no additional Social Security taxes due above that amount.

If you find yourself just inches above the 15 percent mark, then, take a good look at whether your current wages are helping or hurting your retirement strategy. Simply slashing your current wages may not be the answer, as the IRS requires business owners to pay themselves ‘reasonable compensation.’ What’s reasonable? It depends on several – sometimes complicated – factors. For this reason, we work closely with business owners to help guide them toward a reasonable income that both parties (the business owner and the IRS) can feel good about, while any lost wages are moved to other areas that can benefit the business owner.

Image credit: basketman23 / 123RF Stock Photo

Client Spotlight

A terrifying home invasion involving men with masks and guns set Pam Wood on an unexpected path to business ownership in 1981….
What happens when you combine a passion for creating, a knack for business, and deep family values? For Scott Klingler, owner of MergeWorks, it resulted…
Bessie M. Irizarry loves embracing a good challenge. It’s one of the many reasons she’s earned respect as a female engineer and business owner in…
San Antonio native Mark Lopez can’t recall a time he didn’t envision himself following the footsteps of his father, a project manager, into the construction…
Siew Pang knows that the key to unlocking the American dream can be discovered by embracing unexpected opportunities….
If you’re a San Antonian, you may not want to imagine your weekend without brunch at the city’s beloved Magnolia Pancake Haus….
Greg Thompson has long respected money and how it can catalyze greater things….
You may not be aware of it, but Don Lasseter has helped you throw a party. How do we know that? He’s the franchise owner…
Land surveyors aren’t known for exceptional customer service. But why shouldn’t they be? David Breaux set out in 1998 to prove that treating customers right…
When Lance Rose sees a business need, he fills it. That’s how he and Terri, his wife of 30 years, have evolved into the proud…
Matt and Lara Bruhn met while in graduate school at Harvard. He served as an officer and F-15C pilot with the U.S. Air Force….
Growing up in Piedras Negras, Coahuila, Mexico—just south of Texas along the Rio Grande—Oscar E. Flores dreamed of becoming a designer….

Blogs and Articles

Digital Assets and Your Taxes

You may have reveled in the Wild West days of cryptocurrency and other digital assets, but we’re entering an era of meticulous record keeping and...

Digital Assets and Your Taxes

Read More

The Goldilocks Rule for Tax Withholding

If you’re like half of Americans this year, you are more dependent on your tax refund to pay for necessities than you have been in...

The Goldilocks Rule for Tax Withholding

Read More

How Inherited Assets Affect Your Taxes

Inheriting assets can be a financial blessing, but it also raises essential tax questions that many heirs overlook. How you manage those assets can have...

How Inherited Assets Affect Your Taxes

Read More

Getting Hit by Someone Else’s Bankruptcy

Finding out that another business or individual who owes your business money has declared bankruptcy can feel like a kick to the stomach....

Getting Hit by Someone Else’s Bankruptcy

Read More

Welcome to Texas: Cutting Tax Ties with Your Previous State

San Antonio is currently one of the fastest-growing metro areas in the nation. If you’re among our new residents, welcome! Before you enjoy the tax-friendly...

Welcome to Texas: Cutting Tax Ties with Your Previous State

Read More

Reaching the Unreachable IRS

Reaching the IRS has always been challenging. With the IRS workforce reduction continuing, many believe your odds of reaching a warm body to resolve a...

Reaching the Unreachable IRS

Read More

How Is Costco Gold Taxed?

Gold, silver, and other precious metals have emerged as standout assets in today’s unpredictable economy due to their ability to remain somewhat independent from stock...

How Is Costco Gold Taxed?

Read More

Yes, You Do Still Have to File Taxes

Early filing numbers are measurably down this year, data security concerns are high, and IRS staffing is in disarray. But if you’re considering scrapping it...

Yes, You Do Still Have to File Taxes

Read More

Retirement Plan Perks for Texas Small Businesses

Retirement Plan Perks for Texas Small Businesses

Read More

Top 6 Worst Social Media Tax Tips

Top 6 Worst Social Media Tax Tips

Read More

What’s Happening with the Corporate Transparency Act?

In March 2025, the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) issued an interim final rule removing the requirement for U.S. companies to report beneficial ownership information...

What’s Happening with the Corporate Transparency Act?

Read More

Love & Marriage & Your Business Assets

Love & Marriage & Your Business Assets

Read More

How Small Business Owners Reduce Taxable Income

How Small Business Owners Reduce Taxable Income

Read More

Spot These Tax Scam Signs Before It’s Too Late

Spot These Tax Scam Signs Before It’s Too Late

Read More

‘Bitcoin Jesus’ Faces Tax Fraud Reckoning

‘Bitcoin Jesus’ Faces Tax Fraud Reckoning

Read More

Now Accepting New Clients

Let’s Start the Conversation

Let’s take a look at your finances together. We offer a complimentary 1-hour call to review your past tax returns. If we see a way to help you, we will.