Refuting Criminal Intent in Business Fraud Cases

Criminal intent can make or break a business fraud case. Yes, intent can be hard to prove, but it’s also difficult to refute when every arrow seems to point to one person, often the business owner.

The case surrounding Theranos Founder Elizabeth Holmes is an example. “Holmes was found guilty on some charges but not others because the jury could not agree about whether she had deliberately deceived investors. Much of her case relied on proving her fraudulent intent,” explains Laura Harris, CFE, who is a research specialist with the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners. “While an individual might be under pressure or have potential incentives to commit fraud, it does not translate directly to the intention to commit fraud.”

Forensic accountants can play a crucial role in helping refute criminal intent by uncovering and examining patterns of behaviors and other clues. Was the business owner overly relying on the professional advice of others? Were they deceived by a bookkeeper or another employee or partner? What about negligence? How likely is it that the business owner eventually realized they made errors but never intended to cause harm?

You can bet the IRS will jump right into analyzing records and other evidence to prove the criminal intent they assume exists. Forensic accountants can mirror those efforts and more. When working as litigation support for the defense, these professionals are trained to find clues that rebut assumptions related to criminal intent. These breadcrumbs often uncover the evidence of harmful advice, intent among employees or partners instead, or negligence.

The work of a forensic accountant is part art and part science as they:

  • Look for hidden transactions, manipulated records, or unusual patterns of behavior.
  • Identify suspicious patterns, trace financial transactions, and reconstruct financial activities.
  • Assess internal control systems to identify vulnerabilities and weaknesses that may be exploited by other individuals.
  • Identify patterns of behavior and potential motives that help mitigate or refute fraudulent intent.

One of our most high-profile cases in this arena is the 1996 U.S. Senate inquiry into Swiss banks’ involvement in hiding assets from Holocaust victims. Steven Bankler was hired to consult for the U.S. Senate Banking Committee and was instrumental in uncovering more assets and victims than had previously been identified.

“The issues Bankler pointed out to the U.S. Senate Banking Committee could only have been uncovered through an expert and thorough understanding of forensic accounting principles, such as which assumptions to disregard,” we previously wrote. You can read the entire story here. Feel free to contact us with questions.

Client Spotlights

A terrifying home invasion involving men with masks and guns set Pam Wood on an unexpected path to business ownership in 1981.
What happens when you combine a passion for creating, a knack for business, and deep family values? For Scott Klingler, owner of MergeWorks, it resulted in a thriving family business known for its…
Bessie M. Irizarry loves embracing a good challenge. It’s one of the many reasons she’s earned respect as a female engineer and business owner in predominantly male-dominated fields.
San Antonio native Mark Lopez can’t recall a time he didn’t envision himself following the footsteps of his father, a project manager, into the construction business.
Siew Pang knows that the key to unlocking the American dream can be discovered by embracing unexpected opportunities.
If you’re a San Antonian, you may not want to imagine your weekend without brunch at the city’s beloved Magnolia Pancake Haus.
Greg Thompson has long respected money and how it can catalyze greater things.
You may not be aware of it, but Don Lasseter has helped you throw a party. How do we know that? He’s the franchise owner of six San Antonio-area Party City stores.
Land surveyors aren’t known for exceptional customer service. But why shouldn’t they be? David Breaux set out in 1998 to prove that treating customers right can pay off in any industry.
When Lance Rose sees a business need, he fills it. That’s how he and Terri, his wife of 30 years, have evolved into the proud owners of OverWatch Enterprises, LLC, a cutting-edge security services company.
Matt and Lara Bruhn met while in graduate school at Harvard. He served as an officer and F-15C pilot with the U.S. Air Force.
Growing up in Piedras Negras, Coahuila, Mexico—just south of Texas along the Rio Grande—Oscar E. Flores dreamed of becoming a designer.

Blogs and Articles

Love & Marriage & Your Business Assets

How Small Business Owners Reduce Taxable Income

Spot These Tax Scam Signs Before It’s Too Late

‘Bitcoin Jesus’ Faces Tax Fraud Reckoning

Tax Considerations of Qualified Settlement Funds

Weighing Taxes When Selling Your Business

Small Business Merger Tax Considerations

Charitable Giving & Your Taxes

Bankler’s Year In Review

What Tax Cuts & the Economy Might Look Like in 2025

Texas Franchise Tax Reminders

Corporate Transparency Act & Your Beneficial Ownership Obligations

Falling Interest Rates and Your Small Business